• 
  Catherine McCafferty

  Audience Member
• 
  Brian Robinson

  2 episodes, 2019
• 
  Tony Rodriguez

  2 episodes, 2019
• 
  Paul Rust

  Self
• 
  Kale Hills

  Brother Paul
• 
  Josh Brekhus

  Patron
• 
  Andrew Ahlquist

  Theater Go-er
• 
  Charlotte Anderson

  Cult Member

• 
  Jace Armstrong

  NASA Commander
• 
  Samira Izquierdo

  Military School Student
• 
  Julie Birke

  Tig
• 
  Zach Broussard

  Super Al
• 
  Nick Cannon

  Self
• 
  Joe Carter

  Military School Student
• 
  Jay Chandrasekhar

  Self

• 
  Raphael Chestang

  Steve
• 
  Nova Chez

  Jennifer
• 
  Casey Wilson

  Self
• 
  Kristen Schaal

  Self
• 
  Rainn Wilson

  Self
• 
  Tig Notaro

  Tig Notaro
• 
  Bobby Moynihan

  Loafy
• 
  'Weird Al' Yankovic

  Self
• 
  Reggie Watts

  Self
• 
  Scout Durwood

  NASA Scientist
• 
  Christine Medrano

  Critic 1
• 
  Katie Marovitch

  New Cult Member