• 
  Karen Barnes

  Self
• 
  Keely Shaye Smith

  Herself - Correspondent (as Keely Shaye Smith)
• 
  Mark Jeffrey Miller

  Richard Cepulonis
• 
  Tammy Arnold

  Karen Walters
• 
  Wes Johnson

  Richard
• 
  Gary Wade Morton

  Armed bank robber
• 
  Adrian Roberts

  State patrolman
• 
  Robert Stack

  Himself - Host

• 
  Jason Vail

  Richard Wodke
• 
  David J. Goldfarb

  Nick (as David Goldfarb)
• 
  Jack Beauchamp

  Self
• 
  John P. Gibbons Jr.

  Self (as Det. John P. Gibbons Jr. ret.)
• 
  Mike Corsini

  Self
• 
  Ray Hock

  Self
• 
  Charles Hall

  Self

• 
  Bruce Cornish

  Self
• 
  R. Ken Johnston Sr.

  Self
• 
  Sheila Isenberg

  Self
• 
  Tom Cassano

  Self (as Supervisory Special Agent Tom Cassano)
• 
  Janet Johnston

  Self
• 
  David Knapp

  Self
• 
  Richard Knapp

  Self
• 
  Ann Bostich

  Self - Duke's Former Housekeeper
• 
  Luis Guadalupe

  Self - Eyewitness
• 
  Don Howarth

  Self - Atty. For Dr. Demopoulos, Former Executor
• 
  Mathew Jameson

  Self
• 
  Wendy Jameson

  Self