• 
  Alexis Bledel

  Stacey
• 
  Michael Ian Black

  Brian
• 
  Kurt Fuller

  Michael
• 
  Jim Gaffigan

  Theo
• 
  Jane Kaczmarek

   Pam (2 episodes, 2013-2014)
• 
  Kerri Kenney

   Gwen (2 episodes, 2013-2014)
• 
  Jason Ritter

   Gavin (2 episodes, 2013-2014)
• 
  Ashlie Atkinson

  Nessa

• 
  Craig Geraghty

   Store Owner (2 episodes, 2014)
• 
  Dustin Ybarra

  Archie
• 
  Jim Ford

  Dad
• 
  John Carroll Lynch

  Ed
• 
  Aasif Mandvi

  Dave
• 
  Joanna Shelmidine

  Drunk Woman
• 
  Tom Walker

  Policeman Phil

• 
  Dominic Colón

  Cashier
• 
  Luke Forbes

  Lester
• 
  Bobby Tisdale

  Announcer
• 
  Marian Pinchoff

  Rudy