• 
  Gary Busey

  Brady
• 
  William Katt

  Marshal Roche
• 
  Abraham Benrubi

  Three-Fingered Rube
• 
  Tyler Mane

  Shadow Rider
• 
  Martin Kove

  Rattlesnake Dick
• 
  Joe Estevez

  Sheriff East (rumored)
• 
  Kathleen Gati

  Miss Josephine (rumored)
• 
  Clarence Gilyard Jr.

  Bass Reeves (rumored)

• 
  Grainger Hines

  Bob Steele
• 
  Peter Koch

  John Stout, Texas Ranger (rumored)
• 
  Laurene Landon

  Miss Josephine
• 
  Ron Masak

  Marshall Bill Hawke (rumored)
• 
  Mel Novak

  Jasper Jones
• 
  Nellie Sciutto

  Odessa Red (rumored)
• 
  Morgana Shaw

  Ranchers Wife (rumored)

• 
  William Shockley

  Catfish Kid
• 
  Sonny Shroyer

  Jasper Jones
• 
  Raoul Max Trujillo

  Geronimo
• 
  Richard Tyson

  Fred Scott (rumored)
• 
  Sheree J. Wilson

  Deputy Marshal Knight (rumored)
• 
  Timothy V. Murphy

  Deputy Dan Tucker
• 
  Ronnie Gene Blevins

  Chad Cooper
• 
  Donna Robinson

  Dr. Alene Suby (rumored)
• 
  Justin Paul

  Cimarron Kid
• 
  Kristal Renwick

  Melissa Walker (rumored)
• 
  Ted Ferguson

  Doc Spiro (rumored)
• 
  Mark Hanson

  Charlie Pierce (rumored)
• 
  Wally Welch

  John Kincaid
• 
  Clint Glenn

  James Walker
• 
  Vic Stagliano

  Charlie Pierce
• 
  Dimitrius Pulido

  Juan
• 
  Nicole Steward

  Miss Pearl
• 
  Vanessa Leinani

  U.S. Marshal Knight
• 
  Christian Ferrarelli

  Bill Doolin
• 
  Leana Lewis

  (rumored)