• 
  Tiffany Browne-Tavarez

  Investigator
• 
  Melissa Malone

  Ashley Russo (voice)
• 
  Madeline Lupi

  Tiffany
• 
  Kevin Cusicanqui

  Rocky (Mugger 2)
• 
  Michelle Lulic

  Adelaide Russo
• 
  Mollie Sperduto

  The Girl in the Cornfield
• 
  Carmine Giordano

  Mugger #1
• 
  Hayley Wayne

  Megan

• 
  Sami Bray

  Caroline
• 
  Alex Santoleri

  Abigail Russo
• 
  Brittini Schreiber

  Stephanie
• 
  Hiram Ortiz

  Jack Russo
• 
  Robert Nicholson

  Victor
• 
  Isabella Mays

  Autumn
• 
  Lauren McCann

  Ashley Russo