• 
  Jenna Leigh Green

  Wendy Nawakowski (rumored)
• 
  Natalie Roy

  Susan Weiss
• 
  Tim Realbuto

  Patrick Nolan
• 
  Nolan Gould

  Jeremiah Rosenhaft
• 
  Mavis Simpson-Ernst

  Aggie
• 
  Drew Powell

  Young Patrick
• 
  Chris Medina

  Tom
• 
  Siobhan Fallon

  Jackie Rosenhaft

• 
  Oscar Nuñez

  Mark Bradley
• 
  Jeanine Bartel

  Wendy Nawakowski
• 
  Colin Hanlon

  Richard Caden
• 
  Kelly Kozakevich

  Lindsay
• 
  Doug Plaut

  Benvolio
• 
  Michael Nigro

  George Saiger
• 
  Gabi Faye

  Samantha

• 
  Cathy Salvodon

  Connie Becker
• 
  Sibyl Santiago

  Connie Becker
• 
  Teresa Hui

  Reporter #1
• 
  Jackie Almonte

  Audience Member (as Jacqueline Almonte)
• 
  Cortney Gift

  Audience Member
• 
  Jarod Lindsey

  Audience Member
• 
  Jason Erik Zacek

  Reporter #2
• 
  Christine McCann

  Reporter #3
• 
  Doug Willen

  Casting Director
• 
  Chris Jehnert

  Student in Play
• 
  Alana Toledo

  Juliet
• 
  Simone Norman

  Chelsea
• 
  Laura Przybilla

  Audience Member
• 
  Tamara S. Hall

  Restaurant Patron (as Tamara Hall)
• 
  Laurie Sheppard

  Tonya, Patrick's Publicist
• 
  Carol Santiago Medina

  Restaurant Patron
• 
  Tai Leshaun

  Audience Member (as Taishae Leshaun)
• 
  Anna Hindman

  Mark Bradley's Make-Up Artist