• 
  Rachel Dratch

   Imaginary Mary (voice)
• 
  William Belleau

   Man
• 
  Maggie Sullivun

   Elderly Wife
• 
  Jill Morrison

   Zoe
• 
  Sunita Prasad

   Alice's Assistant
• 
  Jason Cermak

   Alice's Father
• 
  Nicholas Coombe

   Andy
• 
  Jaime Callica

   Hot Male Bartender

• 
  Kadence Kendall Roach

   Alice - 11 Years Old
• 
  Will Verchere-Gopaulsingh

   Boy
• 
  Matreya Scarrwener

   Dora
• 
  Erica Tremblay

   Bunny
• 
  Brett Pierce

   Gabe
• 
  Jenna Elfman

  Alice
• 
  Stephen Schneider

  Ben

• 
  Jennifer Chu

   Clara (2 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Denise Jones

  Florence
• 
  Bronwen Smith

  Megan
• 
  Jeny Cassady

   Mary Puppeteer (9 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Diana Bang

  Gigi
• 
  Natalie Morales

  Rebecca
• 
  Marin Page

  Alice (Age 6)
• 
  Lauren Stamile

  Rene
• 
  Jilena Cori

  Mother (Alice age 6)
• 
  Richard O'Sullivan

  Stacey's Dad
• 
  James Rha

  Agent